LHC fires up!

From various sources in the science blogotopia, we learn that the LHC has been started for the first time!   For those unfamiliar, the LHC (Large Hadron Collider) is designed to be the world’s largest particle accelerator, which will probe the frontiers of known physics in search of a greater understanding of the fundamental forces of nature.

I don’t have a lot to say on the start up of the LHC itself, other than the fact that it’s very exciting (I did undergraduate and graduate work in high-energy physics, so I have a bias).  I can’t resist, however, pointing out CNN’s initial lede on the subject:

Scientists applauded as one of the most ambitious experiments ever conceived began today. The Large Hadron Collider — designed to simulate conditions of the Big Bang — was switched on this morning. Skeptics claim the experiment could create a black hole capable of swallowing the Earth.

Emphasis mine.  This is highly misleading, as the ‘skeptics’ in question to the best of my knowledge have no scientific experience and are contradicted by every reputable scientist on the planet.  The structure of the story has changed since I first read it, but it still highlights the concerns of the ‘skeptics’.  Just for fun, let’s look at what some other CNN ledes might look like if given similar skeptical counterbalance:

Concerning Hurricane Ike:

Residents along part of the Texas Gulf Coast have been told to leave Wednesday morning after Hurricane Ike left Cuba and began to gain strength in the warm Gulf of Mexico.  Skeptics scoff at the notion that the hurricane will do significant damage, and suggest that its cleansing rains will wash away all the bad mojo in the region.

Concerning Lehman Brothers suffering a $4 billion loss:

Lehman Brothers suffered one of its worst quarterly losses in the company’s history, reporting a loss of nearly $4 billion Wednesday, and announced a series of drastic steps aimed at reviving the beleaguered firm.  Skeptics deny the loss of the money: “How could $4 billion dollars just disappear!!1??”

Concerning an earthquake which hit southern Iran:

A strong earthquake measured at magnitude 6.1 Wednesday demolished nearly 200 villages in Iran, leaving at least one person dead, local media reported.  A skeptic says:  “Aaahh!!! Spiders!!! All over me!!! Can’t you see them!!?? Get ’em off!!!”

This entry was posted in Science news. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to LHC fires up!

  1. Yoo says:

    “Government takes over Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Skeptics say this can cause a cascade of takeovers, turning the country into a communist state.”

  2. Babs67 aka the fiancee says:

    Adding those kinds of comments to their ledes is annoying, but may be necessary to get their average reader to engage. People aren’t interested in that complicated science stuff unless there’s a chance it could change all of life as they know it.

    Kind of like when the 11 o’clock news has a commercial at 9 telling you to tune in at 11 to find out what common household article COULD KILL YOU!!

  3. Yoo: Well put! You have a future in ‘balanced’ news reporting! 🙂

    Babs67 wrote: “Adding those kinds of comments to their ledes is annoying, but may be necessary to get their average reader to engage. ”

    I don’t mind them spicing up their stories, but pushing demonstrably false and frightening stories does nobody any good — and can actually kill people.

  4. t man says:

    to suggest some Hannis reaction is to suggest that it is possible to happen. Therefore setting the wheels of creation or manifestation in motion.
    when this is done it will cause a better chance of the contrary event to happen im willing the opposite but the more they tell us it could happen the better the chances of it actually happening become more and more possible the more minds that think about it can steer it into existence.
    therefore, ANYthing is possible if it requires a thought to awaken the existence of the subject into reality that we live in.
    again think positively and nothing bad will ever happen people.
    we can change our future if we choose so.good or bad you are the creator weather you know it or not.

  5. Pingback: Destroying the planet… with science! | Skulls in the Stars

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.